A Polite Fiction: In Confidence, an Auspice Story Game
by Team@DyversHands.com
$0+
A whisper says one of us is writing it all down.
A Polite Fiction: In Confidence is a standalone GM-less story game of masks, whispers, and one poisoned pen. You are a circle of friends at the Grand Hotel, and a whisper walks the halls: one of you, it says, holds the Poison Pen, the hidden hand that trades in what was told in trust. It is told entirely through prompt cards answered aloud, in the wider tradition of Alex Roberts’ For the Queen. It needs no GM and no prep: three to four storytellers, this deck, and an evening.
A story game of masks, whispers, and one poisoned pen. 3–4 storytellers, one evening, gmless.
Nothing fixes the century. The Hotel, the Society outside it, and the circle within it can be imagined in any tradition your table likes: a Regency salon, a gilded spa hotel, a 1920s medical convention. The cards stay period-neutral, and the table decides what it is looking at.
Print-and-Play
In Confidence is delivered as a PDF to print at home on seven Avery ten-up business-card sheets (or equivalent). Punch out the deck and you are ready to play. No dice, no board, and no art, by design: what the Hotel and its season look like is yours to imagine.
What is In Confidence?
In Confidence is one season, told in a single evening. Each storyteller speaks for one member of the circle, in their own voice, and the season is built one answered question at a time. On your turn you draw a prompt, read it aloud, and answer it as who you are this season, letting what the question takes for granted become true as you speak.
One of the prompt cards from the Masks, the season’s first tier.
There is no facilitator and nothing to prepare. Five Truth cards are dealt at setup, and each tells its holder what to ask the table: they establish the circle, the two factions of Society, the Hotel, the Pen, and the season’s calendar. By the last card, the table has built its own season and taken up its Faces, the roles the circle plays lightly.
The Season is the Clock
The deck runs in three tiers that tighten as the season fills, called movements rather than acts, because the season rises to a single break.
The Masks · Ambient suspicion. The Hotel, the circle, and the games everyone is playing. Courtesies with debts folded into them.
Behind the Veil · Secrets surface, loyalties move, and the suspicion turns pointed. Prompts start handing themselves to particular people.
The Crossroads · Highest pressure, blind choices, masks still up. What would you trade to end the whisper, and who would pay for it?
Slotted among the tiers are four dates the whole table sets as Scenes: the Arrival, the Debut, the Mixer, and the Grand Ball. That Social Calendar is also the clock. The Pen speaks at every date, its last word falls at the Grand Ball, and nothing else ends the season.
The Pen and its Archive
The Poison Pen is never dealt and never held. No storyteller is secretly the Pen. It is fiction the whole table writes, a letter at a time, and its authorship is the question the ending settles.
A prompt marked with the Pen’s nib puts fresh Poison in play mid-season.
A prompt marked with the Pen’s nib ✒ puts fresh Poison in play mid-season. Answer it, and the card goes face-up to the center: the Pen’s Archive, everything the Pen has published this season. Once in the game, each storyteller may also send an answer of their own to the Pen. Say so the moment after you give it, then read it again as the Pen will publish it: the same facts, wearing a new meaning.
The Unmasking, and the Reckoning
At the Grand Ball the masks come down, and here is what makes this one different from a mystery. There is no hidden answer waiting to be turned over. The circle settles the truth together, using the season’s own answers as evidence: whose hand was the Poison Pen? One of ours. A hand beyond the circle. Or all of ours, feeding the Poison a little at a time. What the circle decides is true.
The Reckoning: the facts have not moved, only their meaning.
Then the Reckoning passes around the table. Each storyteller takes one thing they said tonight and tells the others what it truly meant. The facts have not moved. Only their meaning has, and every kind word said this season gets read again for what it really was.
Key Features
A settlement, not a reveal. No traitor role, no secret to protect, nothing to flip over at the end. The table authors the answer together from what it actually said.
Every answer is evidence. The season’s kindnesses come back at the Reckoning wearing a different face. What you say early is the material the ending is made from.
One question at a time. No GM, no prep, no dice. If you can answer a question, you can play.
Period-neutral by design. The register invites a gilded, watchful Society without naming a decade, so the same deck plays a Regency salon or a 1920s convention without changing a card.
Text-only by design. Nothing is pictured, so nothing narrows what you imagine.
Example Prompts
The room is full of people you must charm and cannot trust. Choose one of the Favored, and tell us the courtesy you’ll pay them tonight, and the thing you actually mean to get for it.
(Ask this of another in the circle.) What have I done since we arrived that you’ve started, quietly, to turn over?
The Pen’s next poison re-tells, almost word for word, something one of us said earlier tonight. Say which, and read it as the Pen tells it: the same facts, wearing a new meaning. ✒
Choose a moment from tonight you will swear, if anyone asks, never happened. What was it, and who else was there to contradict you?
How to Play
Gather three to four storytellers, the deck, and an X-Card for safety. Work through the five Truth cards to build your season, take up your Faces, and agree together on what you do and don’t want in tonight’s story. The X-Card removes anything from the game: name what goes, and owe no reason why.
Then take turns. Draw from the current tier, read the prompt aloud, answer it, and set it face-down. Some prompts open with a direction, (Hand this card to…) or (Ask this of…): do as the card says, and the one it reaches answers. Nib prompts ✒ go face-up to the Pen’s Archive instead. When a tier runs out, open the next. When the Grand Ball has played, the masks come down.
A season is one evening, start to finish: the Truth cards build it, the three tiers run it down, and the Aftermath closes it.
A Lineage of Whispers
The reference genre is the drama of manners in its gilded, grand-hotel register: Edith Wharton and Vicki Baum’s Grand Hotel rather than Austen’s courtship plots. If your way in is Bridgerton, the door is open, though what plays best here is a circle with less protection than that: people past their debut and outside the marriage plot, for whom reputation is not a prize but the whole of their capital. That is exactly where a poison pen bites hardest.
The games behind it are a lineage of their own. In Confidence takes the shuffle-and-answer deck of Alex Roberts’ For the Queen and gives it a season with a clock, and it owes its collective ending to a hidden-role mechanic that was designed, played, and then cut, once the prompts turned out to be doing that job already.
Examples of Play
The kindness that curdled: early in the Masks, someone pays a graceful compliment where the room can hear, and privately names the debt they meant it to make. Three movements later the Reckoning brings it back, and the table learns the compliment was the first thing the Pen ever printed.
All of us, a little at a time: the circle reaches the Unmasking with no single hand to blame, and settles that every one of them fed the Poison. Nobody planned it. It is simply what the season’s answers turned out to say.
An Ashcan Edition
This is an ashcan alpha of In Confidence. Ashcan is a comics term for the rough edition a creator lets out before the art and the polish are anywhere near done. It is complete and playable, but still finding its final shape, and the deck carries an Alpha Test card: if you play it, your notes are welcome and steer where it goes next.
A content note. The pressure in this game is entirely social: slander and reputation ruin, betrayal of confidence, social exclusion, and suspicion among friends. There is no violence and no horror in it. The X-Card is agreed at setup and stays within everyone’s reach.
Get More, Free
A Polite Fiction: In Confidence is one of our Print-and-Play Auspice™ question-driven GM-less story games, and you name a fair price for it. See also Auspice: The Launch 🚀, a story game of exodus and taking root, and Tableau: Dark Expeditions, from our Tableau™ line inspired by Belonging Outside Belonging, built on Tableau: Accelerated. Sign up to our announcement-only email for more games to come from Dyvers Hands Productions!
Final Thoughts
In Confidence is about what a circle does when it cannot trust itself, and what is left of a friendship after everything gets read twice. Speak in your own voice, listen closely to the others, and remember that everything you say tonight is going to come back.
Written & Designed by Christopher Allen
In the lineage of Alex Roberts’ For the Queen. Safety tools adapted from the X-Card by John Stavropoulos.
©2026 Dyvers Hands Productions, LLC. Text as a Free Cultural Work under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) 4.0 license.
In Confidence is a text-only game by design; it contains no images other than emoji.
A Polite Fiction™, Auspice™, and Dyvers Hands™ are trademarks of Dyvers Hands Productions, LLC.